writing community
Sign In Here | Lost Password | FREE Sign Up
E-mail: Password:
Remember login  
The place for writers:
Upload your writing in minutes, receive peer feedback from other writers, poets, authors, then get your work published out there in the real world.       Learn how other writers are doing it.

 
ThePenguin
Peter Budvietas
New Zealand, Auckland

My Bookshop
Words: 244
Access: Public
Comments: 7

Forward to a friend
Print Version
E-mail this writer E-mail this user 
View Author profile
Add to Readers  




The Bathtub Test

You might have seen in in the bulletins, my little prodder called The Bathtub Test" (that's a clickable link, if you want to read it).

Had a talk with a psychologist (no, not the one in the tst blurb) and happened to mention it. His version of why so many people don't "pull the plug"...

"It depends on how you define 'sanity'. To psychologists, as opposed to psychiatrists, sanity is about what's normal. In other words, your 17 people who said 'use the bucket' are the ones who are normal. They are reacting to the question because of the way they are educated.

"Most people do. State a problem, and they attempt to solve it with the givens in the problem. They'll keep on trying, even when there's no solution through the givens. Oh, they'll eventually give up, with the problem unsolved, but, if they go back to it, they'll continue with the givens - the idea of the bucket, cup, teaspoon because they're all containers of "a" solution.

"It's how most people are taught to think and problem solve."

Sad, isn't it?

Maybe that's why so many people are willing to let someone else solve the problems, why so many organizations assume that they can save money by not providing services until absolutely essential.

Maybe the terrorists are right - we've gotten so used to having the solutions in the givens that we are not willing to think outside the box those givens create.

Want to comment on this Blogs?
Sign up to Edit Red and you will be able to comment on Blogs and get access to: Upload your own stories and poems, get readers and their feedback, promote your work...
Sign up






[Back to top]


My Bookshop

Comments  
Boonrassi Comment by: Boonrassi - 2008-02-24 08:52
Add to Readers
      
"Most people do. State a problem, and they attempt to solve it with the givens in the problem. They'll keep on trying, even when there's no solution through the givens.

//haha...

Sad, isn't it?

//yep..
thanks man.. that was fun.
and good use of dialog.. show some others how to
do that.
T
Cherley Comment by: Cherley - 2007-12-19 09:55
Add to Readers
      
Gosh, I gave up years ago on trying to figure out if I'm normal or not. Somewhere I faintly remember I'm Ok, You're Ok. Must have been a doozie of a book, since I don't remember any of it besides the title.

People are interesting. We do tend to fall into groups even if we think we're individual.
danae Comment by: danae - 2007-11-24 19:06
Add to Readers
      
So many people want someone to tell them it all right, they're all right, just like when they were little kids and they would get it from the parents.
People are too scared to "pull the plug"
They are the people that need to have a problem to exist; if there isn't one, they manufacture it..
Dana
Chris Millar Comment by: Chris Millar - 2007-11-19 08:35
Add to Readers
      
What we have here is experience over options. People are great creatures of habit, and having found a solution to a particular issue will return to said solution indefinatly before they look for another way, thus the bucket answer.

I showed this puzzle (?) to a friend who is a psyciatric nurse, who said most of his clients (not patients you may note) would pull the plug out. Thus as a test of sanity i question this method.

Personaly i question the need to empty the bath, it may be perfectly happy as it is thank you very much.
ripleym Comment by: ripleym Online- 2007-11-13 21:57
Add to Readers
      
You hit upon two key points for me there Peter, with reference to organisations seeking external support for problems and the whole thinking outside the box idea.

In my experience, it is often the external contractor who attempts to solve the problem using givens (I prefer to use gibbons, myself), laregely due to a limited time in which to provide results, but often because they have no company loyalty and just want to get a job done and move on to the next contract.

That leaves the solutions people (like myself) feeling disgruntled, because we have maybe noticed the plug chain dangling there teasingly, or wondered whether we could fashion some kind of automated pump out of the bits lying around.

Good blog nontheless!!
1 2 Next

Sponsored Ads


By ThePenguin

Featured Writers

Advertising - Terms & Conditions - Short Story Submissions - Contact - Writing Competitions - Writing Links - Book Promotion - Sky-Tribe.com - alanemmins.com
  Member short stories, poems, comments and other contributions are owned by the poster.
Copyright 2003 - 2007 Edit Red I/S