If you're writing @ Edit Red Writing Community

Please read the forum rules before posting.

jauhar
Violet Alma
United States

Just as the title says.***If you’re writing I’m reading.***

Okay so there are a lot of people on the site who are crying that no on is reading their work.

Paste a link of your work and I’ll read it.
Don’t expect a lengthy review from me I’ll read and make brief comments and grade your works with stars.

*****- Excellent
****-Very good but needs work done on it.
***_ Needs reconstruction
**_ Go back to the drawing board.
*_ You can’t even write your name.
_ What the hell was this.

RULES
1. One entry only for individual.
2. No more than 1500 words, for short stories (I get bored quickly)
3. I’m only reading the first 15 entries if I’m not too bored I’ll extend.
4. Deadline 15-05-2008

mynamelez Online E-mail this user Add to Readers 10/05/2008	If you're reading then I'd better be writing. Here's something from my 2006 archives http://www.editred.com/Uploads/st_76202_The_Symbolic_Bakery (what the hell was this?)

DrCarter2001 Online E-mail this user Add to Readers 10/05/2008	Bummer. I was going to post one but it's 2000 words. Quoth Maxwell Smart: "Missed it by that much!" Oh wait, I didn't realize you worked for Matador, Violet. So here's one I was thinking about submitting: http://www.editred.com/Uploads/st_74347_All_Trains_Go_To_Perpigna Would be helpful to know if it's ready for prime time or not. Thanks. Post edited on: 10/05/2008 03:52:17 AM

akabinny Online E-mail this user Add to Readers 10/05/2008	I think this is a neat idea. Here's one I wrote yesterday that I'm aiming toward eventual publication and I'd love some more thoughts on. http://www.editred.com/Uploads/st_76176_Ciao_Edie Ciao, Edie Post edited on: 10/05/2008 08:36:02 AM

Mayzie71 E-mail this user Add to Readers 10/05/2008	Dead Dreams I entered this into an open prompt contest with a 500 word limit and I am curious to get opinions aout it. This is the first time I have written anything that didn't need broken into chapters, other than poetry. Your welcome to be honest as you like but please just don't be insulting, I am here to learn. Post edited on: 10/05/2008 08:42:53 AM

DrCarter2001 Online E-mail this user Add to Readers 11/05/2008	Thanks Violet. Your feedback is very helpful and I see your point. I'm still new to travel writing so all tips are appreciated.

WLC E-mail this user Add to Readers 11/05/2008	I don't want to come off as snarky, but have some questions---what are your qualifications to rate others with what appears to be heightened confidence in your own superiority? Are you a teacher/instructor? Do you have any degrees in the craft? Because if not, you can do more harm than good if you're not very careful with your critiques. I was on the receiving end of a ego maniac once. Subsequently, after beginning a professional writing course I discovered the ego-manny was wrong about much. There's being helpful and then there's: "you can't even write your name" and "what the hell was this." Respectfully submitted. wlc

Jorbian Online E-mail this user Add to Readers 11/05/2008	http://www.editred.com/Uploads/st_76042_The_Nymph Take your best shot.

jauhar Online E-mail this user Add to Readers 11/05/2008	******************************************************************* No one is oblige to summit anything. Only if you think you need some feed back summit or would like opinion with a difference. For heavens sake no one is perfect.

wgallant E-mail this user Add to Readers 14/05/2008	Hi Violet, Check this out, please. http://www.editred.com/Uploads/st_76384_R_E_S_P_E_C_T Whatchumeen "No one is perfect"? I'm the perfect me.

1

[Back to top]

Reply to this post:

You must be a member and logged in to take part in the Edit Red forum.

Sign up for FREE here.